Property Tax in Cattaraugus County
via TaxByCounty
Cattaraugus ranks above state and national
Cattaraugus County's effective tax rate of 2.693% exceeds both the New York state average of 2.046% and sits above national norms. The median property tax of $2,946 nearly matches the national median of $2,690, though on a much lower median home value of $109,400 versus the national $281,900.
Among highest-taxed New York counties
Cattaraugus ranks in the upper quartile of New York's 62 counties for effective tax rates at 2.693%. This makes it one of the pricier places to own property in the state relative to home values.
Higher taxes than surrounding areas
Cattaraugus's 2.693% rate exceeds Chautauqua County's 2.386% and Allegany County's 2.943%, placing it in the upper range for southwestern New York. Though home values are modest ($109,400), the elevated rate creates one of the region's tightest tax burdens.
Budget roughly $2,946 annually
On a median Cattaraugus home worth $109,400, expect to pay approximately $2,946 in annual property taxes. With a mortgage, the bill rises to $3,383; without, it falls to $2,646.
Appeal your assessment to save
At this tax rate, an overassessment of just $5,000–$10,000 translates to $150–$300 in wasted taxes yearly. Filing a free appeal takes weeks and could permanently lower your tax bill by hundreds.